Print View

Your printed page will look something like this.

Appellate judges send Lowell Area Schools back to court

An appellate court has sent a previously dismissed lawsuit filed by a member of the conservative group Moms for Liberty against Lowell Area Schools back to court. 

Stefanie Boone, a mother of three Lowell Area Schools students, filed a lawsuit in federal court in 2024 alleging the district and district leaders had violated the First Amendment, the 14th Amendment and Title IX.

The case was dismissed in September 2025, with a judge writing that Boone had failed “to allege that the school violated her first amendment rights by requiring her to contact a principal or superintendent before directly contacting school employees.” 

Boone appealed the dismissal to the U.S. Court of Appeals, and the judges remanded the lawsuit to the Western District Court in Grand Rapids Tuesday.  

Court records show that Lowell Public Schools sent Boone a letter in January 2024 requesting she ” immediately cease and desist from any reference to any Lowell Area Schools employee on social media and/or other public communication platforms.” 

This request came after Boone had made multiple social media posts naming Lowell Area Schools teachers and staff, criticizing social-emotional learning; diversity, equity and inclusion; and LGBTQ+ library books. 

The January 2024 letter said some posts could “be construed as threatening in nature” and informed Boone the district would use “all available legal remedies” if she continued making such posts. 

The appellate judges ruled Tuesday that Lowell Public Schools had not violated Boone’s 14th Amendment rights or Title IX but wrote “the Social Media Policy constitutes a coercive threat of legal action sufficient to state a First Amendment claim.” 

“Although the Social Media Policy is self-styled as a ‘request,’ it contains legalistic language … and explicitly broaches the possibility of legal action if Boone does not ‘immediately’ comply,” a judge wrote. “A friendly, ‘wouldja mind?’ from the next-door neighbors, this is not.” 

READ THE FULL ARTICLE HERE