PayPal Protects Free Speech, Revises Policies on ‘Hate’ and ‘Intolerance’
In a victory for free speech, PayPal recently revised its policies and added protections against debanking customers based on their religious or political viewpoints.
“ADF commends PayPal for taking this step in the right direction and making these significant policy changes to further advance the company’s ‘commitment to fair, consistent, and objective account management,’” said Alliance Defending Freedom Senior Counsel Caleb Dalton.
PayPal, co-founded by Peter Thiel, is one of the world’s largest financial technology companies facilitating online money transfers.
The company’s change comes after the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency released a report, “Debanked: Guaranteeing Fair Banking for All Americans,” finding that our nation’s largest banks routinely discriminate and “debank” individuals and organizations based on their political or religious views.
“Debanking” occurs when a bank denies or discontinues individuals’ or organizations’ access to financial services and accounts because, ostensibly, of the perceived “risk” of doing business with them.
Under its earlier policy, PayPal prohibited transactions involving “the promotion of hate, violence, racial or other forms of intolerance that is discriminatory.”
This subjective standard allowed PayPal, which has a poor track record of keeping politics out of its business, to deplatform and debank users based on political or religious views it disfavored.
For these reasons, when PayPal applied for deposit insurance with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) for PayPal Bank, the company’s Utah-based industrial bank, ADF objected.
According to a comment letter ADF filed with the FDIC, PayPal axed its expansion plan in Charlotte, North Carolina after the state passed a law requiring individuals to use bathrooms according to their sex.
Company CEO Dan Schulman said at the time, “[This law] perpetuates discrimination and it violates the values and principles that are at the core of PayPal’s mission and culture,” adding later that, “[B]usinesses needed to be a force for good in those values and issues they believe in.”
ADF detailed several instances where PayPal retaliated after a customer expressed views the company disagreed with.
In one example, PayPal terminated the account of Dr. Colin Wright, an evolutionary biologist, who used the financial company to receive funds for his publication “Reality’s Last Stand,” which critiques gender ideology.
In another example, PayPal froze the account of Moms for Liberty, a nonprofit group focused on protecting parental rights in education, on the same day Florida Governor Ron DeSantis spoke at the organization’s conference. PayPal said it couldn’t allow the organization to operate its account until the IRS approved its 501(c)(3) status.
PayPal unfroze Moms for Liberty’s account access after DeSantis proposed legislation in Florida guaranteeing fair access to financial services, even though Moms for Liberty’s tax status hadn’t changed.
These examples, and others, demonstrate PayPal’s consistent pattern of retaliating against and debanking individuals for disfavored speech and activities.
Following ADF’s complaint to the FDIC, PayPal revised its policies and dropped the subjective prohibition on “hate” and “intolerance,” instead pledging to make business decisions based on “characteristics protected under applicable law.”
The new policy also narrows the scope of its prohibition on “misleading information,” limiting it to communications regarding PayPal transactions.
As a result, ADF has dropped its objection to PayPal’s application for FDIC deposit insurance for PayPal Bank.